Amanda Seyfried & Dominic Cooper ‘Taking a Break’

In a recent interview, Amanda Seyfried said she wasn’t sure if her British beau Dominic Cooper is “the one.” As it turns out, he isn’t — at least for now.

PEOPLE confirms that Seyfried, 24, and Cooper, 31, are no longer dating. “Amanda and Dominic have been on and off for a while — and right now they’re taking a break,” a source says. “But they’re great friends and could still get back together.”